The Electoral university is a mechanism our nation has always used to selected our president, yet what is it, and is that still useful for ours country? once the Constitution to be drafted in 1787, the framers needed a system to selected the president. One team of delegates wanted the president to be elected through a well-known vote (the votes actors by citizens), while various other delegates want Congress to decide the election. They climate made a compromise, and the Electoral College was formed. 

The Electoral college is a group of world chosen by state legislatures to vote for the president and also vice president. The number of electors in every state is equal to the variety of members each state has actually in Congress. Over there are at this time 538 electors, (535 for the variety of representatives in Congress, plus 3 electors who stand for Washington, D.C.). 270 electoral votes are required to victory the presidential election, regardless of who wins the well-known vote.

You are watching: Which is a major flaw in the electoral college system?

Despite separation, personal, instance Americans spreading our ballots for who we desire to it is in president, the only votes the count room those of the Electoral College. 

Electoral Votes have the right to override the famous vote, usually rendering citizens’ votes useless. An instance of a candidate shedding the well-known vote if winning the presidency to be the 2016 election. Hillary Clinton winner the renowned vote with 65,845,063 votes, which to be 2,868,691 votes more than the 62,980,160 of well-known votes cast for Trump. However, she lost the election as result of having 227 electoral votes come Trump’s 304.


“So, according to what the framers wanted, the Electoral college casts votes based on who we space voting for. That means it’s it s okay that the chairman isn’t elected through the renowned vote, yet that my poll still has some impact, right?”

Well, not necessarily. One flaw of the Electoral university is something dubbed “faithless electors.” Faithless electors are electors that will poll for that they desire to be chairman regardless the the renowned vote. Over there are about 30 claims that call for their electors to poll for the candidate that wins the famous vote, yet there are still about 20 states that don’t have any laws restricting electors. If you to be voting in a state through a faithless elector, your vote might essentially not count. 

Click right here for an ext information on faithless electors.

Another aspect that might make your vote also less impactful is living in a an ext populated state. For example, in Wyoming, there space 578,000 people and three electoral votes, which is identical to one electoral vote for every 190,000 voters. However, in California, over there are around 40 million people and also fifty-five electoral votes, i m sorry is indistinguishable to one for every 700,000 voters. 

This method that the votes of world in Wyoming are about 3.5 times together impactful as those in California. 

There is however another, if no the biggest flaw: In 48 that the 50 states, electoral votes are managed through something dubbed the “winner-take-all” system. In winner-take-all states, just one candidate gets all of all of the electoral votes for that state. For example, in California, if candidate X gets 45 electoral votes, and candidate Y it s okay 10 electoral votes, all 55 votes go to candidate X–even though human being represented by the 10 electors voted because that candidate Y. 

As a an outcome of the winner-take-all system, a presidential candidate could hypothetically victory an choice by winning just 11 states.


With every one of these flaws in the Electoral college system, what have the right to be done about it?

One noticeable solution would be to totally get rid of the Electoral College. Abolishing the Electoral university would need amending the Constitution, which is a an extremely long and complicated process. First, once an idea has enough popular support, a member that Congress bring it to the floor of one of two people the residence or the Senate. The room of conference the idea was introduced in assigns a committee to debate and also refine the idea. If the idea provides it out of the committee, the complete chamber will debate. Because that the amendment to proceed, two-thirds of the room it was introduced in has to vote for it. The process will be repeated in the other chamber. If two-thirds of congress votes because that the amendment, the revised gets sent out to every state. Once 3/4 the the claims ratify it, the amendment lastly passes. The Constitution has only been amended 27 times due to the fact that it walk into effect in 1789.

An easier solution to the Electoral College difficulty would it is in to simply remove the winner-take-all system. This would require individual state legislatures to adjust their laws. Gaining rid of the winner-take-all system way that candidates would certainly receive any type of electoral votes actors for them cast for them, nevertheless of whether or no they winner the bulk of electoral votes of electoral votes from the state. A solution like this wouldn’t have to go with the constitutional amendment process; the states would have it to execute themselves. This would certainly be faster, and also would it is in a action towards make everyone’s votes count.

See more: Columbo A Bird In The Hand Cast, Columbo A Bird In The Hand

You have the right to do your part in repairing a flawed device by sending messages the encourage electoral revolutionary to her representative in Congress, and by bringing fist to this concern by telling friends and also family. 

We assistance the Brennan facility for Justice who is advocating because that the Electoral university to it is in reformed, and also we recommend you visit your website for an ext information ~ above the problem of the Electoral university system.